About the author
More posts by Moderator
You are here:
Baking is one of my favorite pastimes. I make a killer banana bread. I love baking cookies and many times, like Marie Barone, bake a cake just because. I follow recipes very closely but always add vanilla even if it is not called for. I can follow those recipes to the letter for one simple reason–I live 900 feet above sea level.
Those who live 2500 feet above sea level cannot enjoy the ease of baking I take for granted. When a recipe calls for a certain amount of flour, they have to add a bit more of the liquid ingredients. If baking powder is needed, the elevated baker must reduce the amount by as much as half. Baking temperatures must be increased. And it isn’t as easy as following specific directions for a perfect cake either. In order to find the perfect balance of everything, copious testing and many failures must ensue. But, just as the elevated baker is finding the correct balance, a thunderstorm hits and their angel food cake comes out of the oven in the shape of a discus.
Such is life in the baking world and such is the idea behind marriage. What works for one couple will not necessarily work for another couple.
Everyone in the world is familiar with JimBob and Michelle Duggar. They are all over television with their TLC program, as well as having been on numerous talk shows and the subject of many a news story. They tow the line of an organization called the Institute in Basic Life Principles (IBLP), and their home schooling program, the Advanced Training Institute (ATI).
IBLP/ATI is run by a chronically unmarried man named Bill Gothard with a storied past, full of scandals. This gentleman has propped himself up as an expert on marriage and everything to do with family life. He is quite the guru with millions of direct and indirect adherents to his ideas. Yes…ideas. Bill Gothard has seven steps to this, fourteen steps to that, twelve steps to everything except alcoholism, three steps to whatever else. The material he puts out is so formulaic, a follower of his has nothing to do but reference any of his hundreds of manuals for any question in life.
As was put forth in ATI material that Michelle Duggar handed out to women at a conference she was speaking at, the formula for marriage is very simple. The wife must worship her husband at every turn in life. She must stand behind him in all his decisions and respect his leadership. She must look at him lovingly whenever he speaks and not interrupt. She cannot argue with him or disagree unless she follows a formula to make a “godly” appeal. All financial decisions are his. All final decisions are his. Her husband’s vision must be her vision and absolute unquestioning trust and faith must be placed in the man she married.
This seems to work well for JimBob and Michelle Duggar. JimBob appears to be an ambitious man and has started numerous businesses. Currently, he is successful at real estate, not to mention the large amounts of money involved in any television show. Trusting a man to make good decisions is very easy when that man works hard, efficiently, smart, and enough to more-than-enough money is rolling in.
The problem is that two people living together is never a cookie-cutter situation. JimBob and Michelle Duggar, as well as all adherents of IBLP/ATI practices, have a favorite line that you will hear whenever they give public interviews or are backed into a corner, defending their ancient and outdated belief system.
“This is simply our conviction.”
No it isn’t. If you dig into the reality of IBLP/ATI/Duggar, you will see what they portray as their conviction is really much more. They posit that, due to their convictions, they have been blessed by God. The obvious conclusion is that if others do not have the same convictions, then God is obligated not to bless them. Thus, the “simply our conviction” line is really a translucent lie.
In 2011, I played on a church softball team. This league was unique in that most of the families showed up to watch their husbands and fathers make fools out of themselves. (Ok, it was really just me making a fool out of myself.) A highlight of the game was the after-party where the home team would bring snacks and drinks and the families enjoyed meeting everyone. My wife and I met a mother of eight children. These children were very poorly dressed and had obvious, easily treatable medical problems (rashes, etc.). We asked the mother how many children she had and she hesitated before she “remembered” that she had eight. The children were well-behaved, but the older girls, around eleven and twelve, were very exasperated while taking care of their younger siblings. The father was nowhere to be found.
I record this scenario here to portray a different side of formulaic marriage and family life as put forth by IBLP/ATI/Duggars. The church league I played in was heavily involved in this mindset and they lived it, even to their detriment. My wife and I went home and began asking the following questions:
All of these questions, and many more can be easily answered when you watch JimBob and Michelle Duggar. They don’t have to worry about them because everything appears to work for this family. But this rosy, happy Hollywood story, is far from reality.
Not everyone has a husband who works hard and “gets lucky.” Many marriages work better when all parties handle everything equally. Many marriages work very well when the partners have extended arguments and constructive fights. Disagreement is good in life. Many families struggle to make a living and need all parties to be gainfully employed. Sometimes the spouse needs to sleep on the couch overnight to reboot the romance. I cannot even begin to list all the real life differences from the perfect life formula that the Duggars portray as absolute and necessary. There are hundreds–and they grow exponentially with every passing hour of life.
Happiness in marriage is what the two married parties make of it. It will look different for every marriage. Don’t let anyone tell you that your marriage would be better (or even worse: truly blessed by God) if you only followed their principled life. It just isn’t true.
Share this post:
Tweet this Share on Facebook Stumble it Share on Reddit Digg it Add to Delicious! Add to Technorati Add to Google Add to Myspace Subscribe to RSSI understand many people fall into this kind of co ...
By Anthony E., October 29, 2020Yes, I agree with you 100%. There are a lot of ove ...
By rob war, September 24, 2020Rob, this also sounds like a variation on the "pro ...
By Jean, September 20, 2020what Bill taught can be summed up with the term "m ...
By rob war, August 27, 2020Indeed. Any attempt to attain righteous by adherin ...
By kevin, August 21, 2020Psalm 34:15-22 (ESV) reading for today (The face o ...
By Larne Gabriel, August 16, 2020Psalm 34:15-22 (ESV) reading for today (The face o ...
By Larne Gabriel, August 16, 2020If every accusation against Gothard were false, an ...
By David, August 14, 2020@Rob War "IBLP's downward spiral began before B ...
By kevin, August 13, 2020Yes, perfect judgement. Bill is no longer the "thi ...
By rob war, August 12, 2020I'm sure Bill and those supporting him are upset w ...
By rob war, August 12, 2020Kevin, Thank you. I had a longer reply, but it ...
By Larne Gabriel, August 12, 2020You have done an excellent job Larne! You state ...
By kevin, August 11, 2020Kevin, Your comment about "Witnesses" is intere ...
By Larne Gabriel, August 11, 2020Hi Rob. Yes, it is a downward spiral. I read some ...
By kevin, August 11, 2020Hi Larne, Good to hear from you. Yes, they have h ...
By kevin, August 11, 2020Rob and Kevin, They have had more than enough t ...
By Larne Gabriel, August 11, 2020Want to donate to the Recovering Grace ministry? Do all of your Amazon shopping using the link below, and a small percentage comes back to us. Or you can donate directly via paypal to [email protected] Note: Recovering Grace is not a 501(c)3, and thus gifts are not tax-deductible.
Copyright © 2011-2014 Recovering Grace. All rights reserved. RecoveringGrace.org collects no personal information other than what you share with us. Some opinions on this site are not the opinions of Recovering Grace. If you believe copyrighted work to be published here without permission or attribution, please email: [email protected]
57 Comments