About the author
More posts by Moderator
You are here:
[Editor’s note: This is Part 4 of a four-part series. Click here for Part 1, Part 2, or Part 3]
—CHOICES—
In Wisdom Booklets and in other manuscripts, Bill teaches that every choice–no matter how trite–is “good” or “evil.” He teaches that “gray areas” indicate a presence of evil because gray is a mixture of light and dark. He teaches that people who believe in “gray areas” operate on a failure to distinguish right from wrong. In the Wisdom Booklet, an example of this is the choice between wearing a clip tie and a long tie. Gothard explains that the gentleman choosing the clip tie made the correct choice that day because he ended up in a battle with a crook who could have strangled him with his tie. In all actuality, the moral decision wasn’t “hmm… what do I wear today?” It was “hmmm… should I obey dress code today and wear the standard-issue tie as mandated by my employer?” (he was a police officer) Obedience was the issue. Not what to wear! We often heard that even the color of the carpet was a moral issue to him. The fact that I don’t believe the choosing of a carpet color is a moral issue doesn’t mean that I don’t know the difference between good and evil. It means that even though I know it’s morally wrong to STEAL the carpet, I believe that the choice of color is a non-moral issue.
—COURTSHIP—
In continuation with Bill Gothard’s step-by-step systematic way to live, there’s the subject of courtship. The term “courtship” comes from the days of old when a man “courted” a woman instead of “dating” her or “going out” with her. Mere terminology. In recent years, “courtship” refers to more of a potentially supervised relationship in preparation for marriage. Bill Gothard’s brand of courtship is intricately linked to his teaching of authoritarian parenting and systematic, mechanistic prescriptions for life. According to Mr. Gothard, each area of life is governed by a military-like chain of command. Therefore, why should dating/courtship be any different? Marriages would surely fall under attack if not gone into without the chain of command in place.
Mr. Gothard is so caught up in his “umbrella of protection” concept that he can’t see reality. He has no idea how REAL families operate. Not Beaver Cleaver families. Not Stepford families. But REAL families. He claims that “Satan cannot get through to some sons and daughters unless there is a leak in the father’s umbrella.” He teaches a philosophy that as long as sons and daughters abide by the demands of the father, their lives will be successful. In his seminars, Bill teaches that if a father/husband’s authority is not properly recognized, then all else will fall apart. If the wife fails to submit to her husband, her children will be rebellious. The success and failure of the family hinges on how everyone in the line of command responds to the father. It really bothers me that Bill refuses to see the countless families under his influence that were falling apart due to power hungry, authoritarian parents and not because of rebellious children. Will he ever wake up and see that the huge generation of parents who were drawn to ATIA were attracted to it because it fed their hunger for self-centered control in the name of religiosity? And so now with his “courtship” development, he’s giving parents continued propaganda about the biblical standard for leading their children to marriage. Every control-obsessed parent’s dream!!!
Back to the pendulum swing again: Scared parents. Perverse society. Huge divorce rate. Then a hero emerges on the scene and provides promising answers.
—CONCLUSION—
I began my relationship with God while under Bill Gothard’s teaching. And like I stated earlier, for a time, I ignored the small little seemingly “non-issues” that I found disagreement with. My thinking was “let’s not throw out the baby with the bathwater.” But Bill Gothard is someone who condones authoritarian parenting, replacing God with self, child abuse, creating choices as non-optional principles by twisting Scripture, and redefining grace erroneously. Therefore, I have been compelled to take a step back and rethink: “This bathwater is so dirtied by extra-Biblical teaching that the baby needs to be found elsewhere.” I hope you’ll take a step back and do the same.
Share this post:
Tweet this Share on Facebook Stumble it Share on Reddit Digg it Add to Delicious! Add to Technorati Add to Google Add to Myspace Subscribe to RSSthank-you for the link. Tim's wife also wrote a le ...
By rob war, June 15, 2025Interesting enough there's another particular lett ...
By BC, June 12, 2025I thought David Waller is married to Anna Duggar's ...
By rob war, May 16, 2025This people the suppossed friends and family membe ...
By BC, May 16, 2025There could be. I am sure that number is rather sm ...
By rob war, May 16, 2025My only concerns are if there are any other IBLP C ...
By BC, May 16, 2025Robert, it's been a long time since I've talked to ...
By Jared Myers, May 8, 2025It is very encouraging to see. There is still hope ...
By kevin, May 3, 2025Wow, I just read the interview with Jason and Magg ...
By rob war, April 29, 2025I read both of Jinger's books; People Pleaser and ...
By JPU, April 27, 2025A consistent application of Romans 5:1 would have ...
By Jared Myers, April 24, 2025I believe that the moderator over on DG had childr ...
By rob war, April 23, 2025Maybe that's true and you did get exposed to that ...
By Jared Myers, April 23, 20251. The Mother Tells The Husband. Good, that was ...
By Jared Myers, April 23, 2025I didn't read this book from her. I am not sure if ...
By rob war, April 23, 2025That would be the eleventh anniversary, he resigne ...
By Larne Gabriel, April 22, 2025His Word extends beyond just the 1611 KJV. Not eve ...
By Jared Myers, April 22, 2025In case anyone is interested, Jinger Duggar has wr ...
By kevin, April 22, 2025Copyright © 2011-2023 Recovering Grace. All rights reserved. RecoveringGrace.org collects no personal information other than what you share with us. Some opinions on this site are not the opinions of Recovering Grace. If you believe copyrighted work to be published here without permission or attribution, please email: [email protected]
[...] post is continued here… The Truth about ATI authority [...]
Donna, very well written. Thank you. You have done a good job of putting to words things I felt but couldn't communicate well. I was one who feels she came out of ATI without emotional or physical scarring, but still can't embrace the ministry anymore.
mrskatie, thanks and hugs to you!
I was just recommended to this site by a dear friend, who was also involved/indoctrinated by IBLP/ATI. Although I have been gone from HQ for many years now, it is relieve and reassuring that I was not crazy to walk away thinking that it had become a very sad place to be. Thanks for your thoughts and perspective!
Thanks Donna!!
well said and thanks.
Loved the last line "the bathwater is so dirtied that the baby needs to found elsewhere!" great thoughts!
[...] members should think, act, and feel (for example, members must get permission to date, change jobs, marry—or leaders prescribe what types of clothes to wear, where to live, whether or not to have [...]
Mr. Bill does not realize there is more than one way to make gray.
As an artist, I can make many shades of brilliant grays and never have to use black paint.
I mix 2 opposites (complementary colors) on the color wheel and then add white. (blue is opposite orange, yellow is opposite purple, red is opposite green).
Artists often use this method because the grays are so much more warm and lively than a tradtional black and white blend.
What kind of spiritual truth can that be turned into? Maybe it is just about artists and how they paint.
[...] [Editor's note: This is Part 2 of a four-part series. Click here for Part 1, Part 3, or Part 4] [...]
I know the Shiny Happy People documentary insinuated that Gothard and the homeschooling movement was motivated by racial school integration, but I always believed it was more of a reaction against the Sexual Revolution of the 60s -- hence the (hyper)focus on courtship and the purity culture.